Feedback Form

Choose a draft in the #feedback channel. Fill out this feedback form. I will forward it to the person who wrote the piece, and CC you. To meet requirements, all fields of the form must be completed. You may repeat this assignment up to two times.

Your name
First Last
Your e-mail address
The name of the student whose piece you're reviewing
First Last
What is the genre of this piece of writing?
What are you understanding as the overall purpose of this piece?
If this piece of writing has arguments in it (i.e. it is a review, the personal essay, etc.), give a brief reverse outline of it below. Summarize the argument of each paragraph in your own words.
For more information on what a reverse outline is, go here: https://writingcenter.gmu.edu/guides/reverse-outlining#:~:text=Reverse%20outlining%20is%20simply%20making,a%20quick%20and%20clear%20way.
Who is the audience that you think the writer might be addressing? Try to be as specific as possible (i.e. don't say "English speakers" or "Americans" — try to think about a specific place or publication where you might see this work appear.) Do you think that you're the audience for it?
As a reader, are there any moments in this piece where you feel confused? Copy and paste them here, and say why you were confused.
As a reader, are there any moments in this piece that particularly stand out to you? Copy and paste them here, and say why they stand out.
What is something you really admire about this piece of writing?
What do you think the next steps for this piece of writing should be?
Read the comment that the writer wrote about their piece in the #feedback channel. Respond to the feedback that the author requested.
You may upload draft comments here if you would like.
Max. file size: 100 MB.

This entry is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International license.